About Us

Meet Your Personal Medicare Indianapolis Shoppers!

Keys to Medicare is the husband-wife duo Jason and Heather Newby. As your “personal shoppers,” we’re here to help you make sense of Medicare enrollment. With so many directions to choose from, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. Our goal is to answer every big and little Medicare question that you have. The right Medicare coverage needs to fit your budget and lifestyle. That’s why education is at the core of what we do. When we can talk through the pros and cons of different options, we’ll be able to find the right policy for you. What’s more, it’s completely free to work with us! Clients never have to pay for our services. When you work with us, the insurance company takes care of our fee—at no extra cost to you. Let us be your Medicare personal shoppers, and we’ll be sure to get you on the right track. We stay up-to-date on all of the insurance companies, compare rate trends and pricing, and even monitor their customer service reputation. Our insight can help give you peace of mind both this year, and in the coming years when you want to have your policy reviewed.

Jason Newby

Jason has been helping clients navigate the complexities of Medicare for so long, he sometimes dreams about giving Medicare speeches.

Since 2005, Jason has helped thousands of seniors learn about their Medicare options. He has a passion for providing education, and he always strives to present a broad selection of plans to fit into your budget and match your needs. During the fall season, Jason devotes his time to quoting anyone who wants to review their Medicare coverage with the newest rates.

Heather Newby

Heather has been in the insurance business since 2005. After spending 12 years growing a full lines property and casualty agency, as well as quoting Medicare insurance, she decided to dedicate her sole focus to helping seniors with their Medicare needs.

Her mission is to serve clients holistically. We can’t find the right Medicare solution unless we first understand every option. An educated choice makes all the difference. That’s why Heather is always happy to answer her clients’ questions.

What Our Clients Say About Us